Which "I Heard It, Too" Short Horror Film Is Better? -- YOU DECIDE

See if you can find anything out there in media publishing or producing that also has its own 'copycat' version due to popularity. Of course we have the "remakes." Those don't count. We're talking about creative works based on something exactly the same. And in the horror genre, this popular Reddit post takes the cake:

"A girl heard her mom yell her name from downstairs, so she got up and started to head down. As she got to the stairs, her mom pulled her into her room and said 'I heard that, too.'"

Scary. You can admit it. How is it that a simple 2-sentence post can scare the dickens out of someone?? It's been scary enough that two separate short films were produced based on it. The question is.... Which one's the scariest??

Is It "I Heard It Too" Horror Short #1?

Or Is It "I Heard It Too" Horror Short #2?

You Be the Judge!

Let me know what you guys think! I want to know which one's scariest! (I personally just can't judge. They're both good.)